Volleyball NOT Ping Pong
How do you question your pupils?
It may be a useful self assessment activity to think about how you question your pupils.
Main Section
How long do most of your interactions with pupils last? A few seconds perhaps - like a game of 'ping pong'?
Is there anything wrong with having so many short interactions? What can be done to make them more rich (long and deep)?
Pupils can be asked to explain their answer. But this can still lead to a ping-pong closed interchange between teacher and individual pupils, with negative impact on classroom dynamics - few contributing; many disengaging.
By contrast, the 'volleyball' approach is where an answer from one pupil is 'opened up' to provide a rich, deep class-wide discussion. This encourages all pupils to think about each question posed by the teacher i.e universal, continuous engagement.
(An alternative model is to get the pupils to pose the questions i.e. "Ask me a question which would test whether I have understood X")
For example, in the "teacher-asks-the-questions model, the teacher might ask “What is the next number in this sequence?”
Pupil 1 may give a correct answer with reason (e.g. "Add 4").
Rather than just saying "Correct" (which closes the interaction), the teacher could ask the rest of the class if they agree, and if they can improve on the reason. (This keeps the interaction open and allows it to get richer.)
Pupil 2 may agree and say “We add 4 to the last number, to get the next number in the sequence.”
Pupil 3 may offer “We add 4 to the previous term to get the next term in the sequence.”
We can clearly see an improvement in the reasons given, leading to a better understanding and more developed mathematical language. The message is: the sum of the whole is more than the sum of the parts.
Probes & Prompts
Are you a volleyball or ping pong questioner?
In your next observation, you may like to ask your observer to focus on teacher pupil exchanges.
Taking Action
Try and get someone to observe part of a lesson with attention specifically on volleyball and ping pong. If you can't get a colleague, some people have successfully asked a student to pay particular attention to questioning style.
Case Studies
Research Sources
There are some good sources of reading for this topic with lots of very recent research into how best to keep discussions going. For example:
Smith, H & Higgins, S (2006) Opening classroom interaction: the importance of feedback, Cambridge Journal of Education, 36(4), pp. 485-502.
Myhill, D. (2006), Talk, talk, talk: Teaching and learning in whole class discourse, Research papers in education, 21(1), pp. 19-41.
Both articles explore how interaction takes place, Myhill looking at patterns of interaction in whole class settings. The authors consider different approaches used by teachers to open up discussion, with Smith and Higgins focussing on the way they respond to children's answers rather than how they ask questions in the first place.
Pratt, N. (2006) Interactive maths teaching in the primary school, London, Paul Chapman Publishing.
This book looks at how maths tends to take place in classrooms and helps teachers to change the patterns of interaction they are currently in.
Categories
Pedagogy