Advanced Search
NCETM
NCETM - Working collaboratively to enhance mathematics teaching
HomeNewsResourcesCourses & EventsResearchCommunitiesBlogsMathemapediaSelf-evaluation
Login
User Name / Email Address:
Password:
Join | Forgotten password?


 
  North West West Midlands South West South East London East of England East Midlands Yorkshire and the Humber North East

dimensions_of_possible_variation


Comment on this item Send to printer  
 
Add to your NCETM favourites
Remove from your NCETM favourites
Add a note on this item
Recommend to a friend
Comment on this item
Send to printer

Dimensions of Possible variation (DofPV)

To appreciate a concept is to know what features of an example can be varied and still it remains an example.

What is it about two line segments meeting at a point which makes them produce an angle? What is it about 3x + 4 = 10 which makes it an example of a linear equation in one unknown? What can be changed without losing this property?
Contents
1 Main Section
2 Probes & Prompts
3 Taking Action
4 Case Studies
5 Research Sources
6 See Also

Main Section

You don’t understand a concept unless you recognise examples of it in a variety of contexts. Actually you need more. You need to appreciate what it is that makes something an example, and this means knowing what aspects or features can change and still it remains an example, and how to construct other examples.

For example: line segments form an angle when there one of the segments is considered to be the initial arm, and the other the final arm, and the angle is the amount of rotation to get from the initial to the final arm.  Of course the segments can change in length (other than zero, perhaps), and the whole image can be anywhere in any orientation in the plane.

For example: a linear equation can be formed by equating two expressions, each formed by … it is actually quite difficult to articulate a definition, yet learners are expected to recognise linear equations in one unknown or variable, and to be able to solve them. They do this by becoming implicitly aware of the features which can change and of how you can alter an equation to produce a more comoplicated one. [see Simultaneous Equation Obstacles]

Ference Marton proposed that learning is about becoming sensitised to possible variation [see variation theory]. Anne Watson & John Mason proposed that to appreciate a mathematical concept it is important to have access to a rich space of examples [see example space]. This means having access to a variety of examples and to construction techniques for creating more.

When providing learners with examples, it is important to make sure that there is a range of examples with variation in the important features, sufficiently close together than learners experience what it is that it is possible to change.

It is also important to recognise over what range that change is actually permitted.  For example, are the numbers involved permitted to be whole numbers, integers, fractions, decimals? This is referred to as the range of permissible change.

Being aware of dimensions of possible variation and their corresponding ranges of permissible change is important as a teacher because very often learners are unaware of some important dimensions, and have only a restricted sense of the permissible change.  

Probes & Prompts

In the textbook you use, how does the author vary the examples or the exercises so as to draw learner attention to the important dimensions of possible variation and their associated ranges of permissible change?

Have you tried getting learners to construct examples of concepts or other objects, perhaps with constraints added?  [see learner constructed examples]

Taking Action

When you provide learners with an example, try to catch what it is that you are aware of as being dimensions of possible variation, and the range of permissible change in each dimension. What do you do, or what can you do, to indicate to learners those dimensions and their corresponding ranges?

With colleagues, take a curriculum concept and construct a set of examples which draw attention  to the important features and possibilities. Then compare these with what is offered in the textbook.

Case Studies

Research Sources

Watson, A. & Mason, J. (2005). Mathematics as a Constructive Activity: learners generating examples. Mahwah: Erlbaum.

Watson, A. & Mason, J. (2006) Seeing an Exercise as a Single Mathematical Object: Using Variation to Structure Sense-Making. Mathematical Thinking and Learning. 8(2) p91-111. 

See Also

Categories

Constructs, Pedagogy

Comments

  Email me when this item receives a comment - You must Login to set this option

There are no comments for this item yet...
Only registered users may comment. Login to comment

Related Items

News Rsrc. Blog Rsch.
Comm. Co. & Ev. M'Pedia

Latest Entries

Popular Entries

 

Legal   Press   Contact   About the NCETM   Recruitment   Suggestions

A Department for Children, Schools and Families initiative to enhance professional development across mathematics teaching