About cookies

The NCETM site uses cookies. Read more about our privacy policy

Please agree to accept our cookies. If you continue to use the site, we'll assume you're happy to accept them.

 

Personal Learning Login






Sign Up | Forgotten password?
 
Register with the NCETM

AS/A Level Further Mathematics Forum


Only logged in users can post to this forum.

Help on trigonometry question

Nigelmca 22 March 2012 14:59
Posts5
Joined22/03/12

Hi All,

I am brushing up on AS Level maths and cannot agree with a text book answer.

Question.
  
Find the least positive value of the angle x.
sin (5x + y) = cos ( y – 3x)
 
 
Answer : I use sin z = cos ( 90 - z ) so z = 5x + y and 90 - z = y - 3x.
Simplifying 5x + y = 90 - y + 3x infers x + y = 45.
I deduce x is the smallest positive value.
 
The book's answer is 11.25.

Many thanks for your time.

Nigel.
Link to this Post   Report this post Report this post

stevencarrwork 22 March 2012 15:31
Posts680
Joined28/07/09
sin is not a one-to-one function so sin A = sin B does not imply A = B

What number was your answer? I couldn't see your answer in your posting.

11.25 looks right to me. 
Link to this Post   Report this post Report this post

stevencarrwork 22 March 2012 15:51 - Last edited by stevencarrwork on 22 March 2012 15:56
Posts680
Joined28/07/09

sin(5x +y ) = sin(90-y+3x) 

sin(5x +y ) - sin(90-y+3x) = 0

 2 sin (x+y-45)cos(4x+45) = 0

 So cos (4x+45) = 0, so 4x + 45  = 90, x =11.25 

Needs checking....
Link to this Post   Report this post Report this post

Nigelmca 23 March 2012 07:46
Posts5
Joined22/03/12
Thank you for your help Steven.


I am unsure why you have not considered the other root in the equation

2 sin (x+y-45)cos(4x+45) = 0

Sin(x+y-45) can also take a value of zero to solve the equation.

So Sin(x+y-45) = 0, so x+y-45 = 0, so x+y =45. Thus x could take a value of 1 degree and y of 44 degrees.

Back to original equation
sin (5x + y) = cos ( y – 3x)
sin((5(1)+44) = cos (44-3(1))
sin 49 = cos41. This is true
0.7547... = 0.7547 .

Anyway I contacted the publishers, OCR, who informed me that the question was probably a misprint and should have been

sin (5x + y) = cos ( 3x – y)

This definitely results in x = 11.25.

Thanks again for your time.


Link to this Post   Report this post Report this post

stevencarrwork 23 March 2012 07:56
Posts680
Joined28/07/09
 I assumed it had to be true for all values of y, or else the question would make no sense.

So I ignored the other solution.

But Cos (3x-y) is identically equal to cos (y-3x), so how can that second problem have a different answer?

That makes no sense.

It is like claiming the solution of x^2 + 2x = 9 is a misprint for   2x + x^2 = 9 , which has a different solution.of.

Link to this Post   Report this post Report this post

stevencarrwork 23 March 2012 07:58
Posts680
Joined28/07/09
Your second question :- sin (5x + y) = cos ( 3x – y)

'This definitely results in x = 11.25.'

If we take x as 1 and y as 44, we get sin 49 = cos (-41)

Which is true.

So the 'solution' is x = 1, just like before.
Link to this Post   Report this post Report this post

Nigelmca 24 March 2012 08:15
Posts5
Joined22/03/12
A few further points to consider.........

The text book has not introduced the AS level student to compound angle or double angle identities where this question is presented, so these solutions are 'out of scope' in this context.

However your comment 'sin is not a one-to-one function so sin A = sin B does not imply A = B' has led me to the solution through another route.

Solution:
sin(5x +y ) = sin(90-y+3x) 
Either 5x+y = 90-y+3x          or            5x+y = 180-(90-y+3x)
x+y=45                                                    x = 11.25

I suppose the answer on the left is discarded because the solution involves multiple values of x and y.

I would prefer to have seen the question reworded as : " Find the least positive value of the angle x which holds true for any value of angle y for which  (5x + y) = cos ( y – 3x).

Anyway, thanks very much for your help, Steven. I will now move onto the next chapter !

    

  
 
Link to this Post   Report this post Report this post

Name withheld 17 July 2018 06:37
This post has been reviewed during our moderation process and blocked because it breaches our terms and conditions